The Absolute Best Italian Restaurants in Columbia [Updated 2025]

It’s been quite the journey, indulging in plate after plate of pasta and savoring the finest tiramisu this charming city has to offer. After extensive taste tests and countless meals shared with friends and family, I’ve narrowed it down to 12 must-visit spots that stand out from the rest.

Why trust my recommendations? Well, I’ve navigated the bustling streets of Columbia, exploring hidden gems and local favorites, always on the hunt for that perfect marinara or wood-fired pizza. So whether you’re a long-time resident or just passing through, get ready to discover some culinary delights that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy!

Tino's Italian Bistro & Wine Bar

Highlights
Great service and atmosphere
Live music enhances dining
Kids eat free on Wednesdays
Courteous personnel
Mixed food quality experiences

Tino's Italian Bistro & Wine Bar is a delightful gem in Columbia that truly captures the essence of Italian hospitality. As I stepped inside, the warm, inviting atmosphere wrapped around me like a soft blanket. The soft glow of sconces and the sound of live music created an ambiance that made it clear I was in for a special evening.

Now, let’s talk about the service! The personnel at Tino's were nothing short of courteous. From the moment I was seated, I felt like part of the family. It's also worth noting that on Wednesdays, kids eat free—a fantastic perk for families looking to enjoy a night out without breaking the bank.

As for the food, while I experienced a mix of culinary highs and a few lows, the standout dishes certainly made up for any missteps. The pasta was lovingly crafted and paired beautifully with the right wine selections.

In conclusion, Tino's Italian Bistro & Wine Bar is a lovely choice for those craving a taste of Italy in Columbia, where the combination of good food, music, and genuine service creates a memorable dining experience.

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Towson.

Scittino's Italian Market Place

Highlights
Top-notch pizza and sauce
Friendly and accommodating staff
Great selection of Sicilian products
Welcoming and pleasant atmosphere
Dine-in and bar options available

Tucked away in the vibrant landscape of Columbia is Scittino's Italian Market Place, a real gem for anyone craving authentic Italian flavors. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the welcoming atmosphere, a blend of rustic charm and modern touches that made me feel right at home.

The menu sings the praises of top-notch pizza and their signature sauce, which has captured my heart (and my taste buds). Each slice was a perfect balance of crust, sauce, and an array of fresh toppings that danced on my palate.

But it wasn't just the food that impressed me; the friendly and accommodating staff made the experience even more enjoyable. Each server seemed genuinely happy to help, offering recommendations from their impressive selection of Sicilian products.

Whether you prefer to dine in or enjoy a drink at the bar, Scittino's has delightful options for everyone. After my visit, it’s easy to declare that Scittino's is not just a spot to eat but a delightful journey into the heart of Italian culinary traditions. It’s a must-visit for anyone who truly appreciates the Italian craft!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Baltimore.

Galliano - Maple Lawn

Highlights
Tasty Lasagna with Meat Sauce
Fantastic for Large Groups
Exquisite Italian Cuisine
Incredible Hospitality
Limited but Good Wine Selection

Galliano - Maple Lawn is truly a hidden gem in the heart of Columbia, and my taste buds are still dancing in delight! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with incredible hospitality that made me feel right at home. The ambiance strikes that perfect balance between casual and chic, making it suitable for everything from family dinners to special celebrations.

As I perused the menu, a particular dish caught my eye: the tasty lasagna with meat sauce. Trust me when I say, it did not disappoint! Each layer was perfectly crafted, with rich flavors that sang harmoniously together. It’s absolutely ideal for large groups, ensuring that everyone leaves with satisfied smiles and full bellies.

One thing to note is the limited but good wine selection—it truly complements the exquisite Italian cuisine. Whether you're a connoisseur or simply enjoy the occasional glass, you’ll find something that hits the spot.

If you’re looking for a place that marries quality Italian food with a warm atmosphere, I wholeheartedly recommend Galliano - Maple Lawn. It’s a delightful experience, packed with delicious options that bring a piece of Italy to Columbia. Mangia!

You might also want to check out the best italian restaurants in Baltimore County.

Maggiano's Little Italy

During my recent visit to Maggiano's Little Italy in Columbia, I was greeted with an inviting aroma that whisked me straight to a quaint trattoria in Italy. The ambiance was warm and lively, perfect for a family gathering or a romantic dinner. I indulged in their signature Lasagna Classico, which was decadently rich and generously portioned. The breadsticks were an absolute delight—soft and served with a delightful marinara. The attentive staff made the experience even more enjoyable. If you're craving authentic Italian cuisine that feels like a hug on a plate, then Maggiano's is a must-visit gem!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Baltimore.

Trattoria Amore

My recent visit to Trattoria Amore in Columbia was a delightful culinary journey. From the moment I stepped in, the charming decor and warm ambiance set the stage for an unforgettable meal. The homemade pasta paired with a rich marinara sauce was a taste of Italy I couldn't resist. Each bite felt like a comforting hug, while the tiramisu I indulged in for dessert was heavenly, with just the right amount of coffee. The attentive staff added to the overall experience, making me feel right at home. If you're seeking authentic Italian flavors, this gem is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best indian restaurant in Columbia.

Eataliano Market & Deli

Stepping into Eataliano Market & Deli felt like entering a charming slice of Italy right in Columbia. The moment I walked in, the aromas of fresh herbs and warm bread enveloped me, setting the stage for a delightful meal. The paninis are a standout—crisp, flavorful, and oozing with melted cheese. Don't skip the homemade pasta; it’s a joyful explosion of taste that transports you straight to the streets of Rome! Service is friendly, adding to the inviting ambiance. For a casual yet authentic experience, Eataliano is a must-visit gem that captures the essence of Italian cuisine.

You might also want to check out the best mexican restaurants in Columbia.

Bertucci's Italian Restaurant

Bertucci's Italian Restaurant is a delightful culinary escape that captures the heart of traditional Italian dining. The warm ambiance sets the perfect tone, inviting you to indulge in their handcrafted pasta and wood-fired pizzas. During my visit, I savored the rich flavors of their famous Margherita pizza, with fresh basil and mozzarella that danced on my palate. The staff was attentive yet friendly, adding to the delightful atmosphere. Don’t skip dessert—their classic Tiramisu is simply divine! Whether for a family gathering or a romantic evening, Bertucci's offers an experience that is both inviting and satisfying!

You might also want to check out the best halal restaurant in Baltimore.

Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico

Stepping into Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico felt like a warm hug from Italy! The cozy ambiance and friendly staff immediately set the stage for a delightful culinary journey. I started with the bruschetta, which was a symphony of fresh tomatoes and fragrant basil on perfectly toasted bread. The star, however, was their wood-fired pizza—the crust was crisp, yet delightfully chewy, topped with an avalanche of gooey mozzarella and vibrant toppings! Don’t miss their homemade gelato for dessert; it's the cherry on top of a fabulous meal. Truly, a hidden gem in the heart of Columbia!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Baltimore Inner Harbor.

Facci Ristorante of Turf Valley

Nestled in the heart of Turf Valley, Facci Ristorante is a delightful gem that offers a captivating blend of authentic Italian cuisine and a warm, inviting atmosphere. The moment you step inside, the aroma of garlic and fresh herbs entices your senses. I savored their signature wood-fired pizzas, which boasted a perfectly charred crust and vibrant toppings. The pasta dishes are pure comfort—each bite is a hug from Nonna herself! With a thoughtful wine selection to complement your meal, Facci is the ideal spot for a romantic dinner or a cheerful gathering. Don't miss this culinary treasure in Columbia!

You might also want to check out the best family restaurants in Baltimore.

Franco's Italian Bistro Catonsville

At Franco's Italian Bistro Catonsville, I was instantly enveloped in a warm, inviting atmosphere that resonated with authenticity. The aroma of fresh-baked bread greeted me as I settled in, setting the stage for what would be a delightful culinary journey. I savored their rich, homemade marinara sauce atop perfectly al dente pasta—each bite was a symphony of flavors that transported me straight to the heart of Italy. The charming staff made the experience even more enjoyable, with their attentiveness and genuine smiles. Franco's is truly a gem, proving that deliciousness can be both classy and cozy!

You might also want to check out the best thai restaurant in Baltimore.

Olive Garden Italian Restaurant

As I stepped into Olive Garden, the inviting aroma of garlic and herbs wrapped around me like a warm hug. The ambiance is casual yet charming, perfect for both family dinners and romantic evenings. I savored their signature Endless Breadsticks—soft, warm, and irresistibly buttery. The Tour of Italy was a delightful medley, showcasing rich lasagna and creamy alfredo that danced on my palate. Plus, the whimsical never-ending salad adds a refreshing crunch! While it may not boast the authentic flair of a hidden gem, Olive Garden certainly provides a comforting Italian experience that feels like home. Mangia bene!

You might also want to check out the best korean restaurant in Baltimore.

Carrabba's Italian Grill

Carrabba's Italian Grill in Columbia serves up a delightful Italian experience that’s both hearty and satisfying. The moment you walk in, the inviting aroma of fresh herbs and simmering sauces envelops you. I indulged in the Chicken Parmigiana, which was perfectly crispy and paired well with their homemade marinara sauce. Don’t skip the Sogni di Cioccolata for dessert; it’s a chocolate lover's dream! The ambiance is lively yet cozy, making it ideal for a romantic dinner or a celebratory family gathering. Overall, Carrabba's effortlessly blends authenticity with a touch of fun, ensuring every visit is a treat!

You might also want to check out the best german restaurant in Baltimore.