The Absolute Best New York Style Pizza in Baltimore [Updated 2025]

I’ve tasted everything from the classic pepperoni to wild gourmet toppings, and trust me, my taste buds have been on quite the adventure! After reviewing 12 top locations, I can confidently say that I’ve uncovered some hidden gems and fan favorites that will have you craving a slice in no time.

With years of munching on the city’s best pies under my belt, I know what truly makes a New York-style pizza sing—the perfect blend of crispy crust, tangy sauce, and gooey cheese. So grab a napkin, because you won’t want to miss out on these delectable spots that are redefining pizza in Charm City!

Little Donna's

Highlights
Cozy Italian atmosphere
Delicious, crispy pizzas
Outstanding lobster pierogis
Knowledgeable, friendly service
Unique cocktail offerings

Little Donna's: A Slice of NY in Baltimore

Stepping into Little Donna's is like being transported to a quaint corner of New York. The atmosphere radiates a charming Italian vibe, wrapping you in warmth as you settle in. Now, let’s talk pizza. The crust? A perfectly crispy masterpiece that strikes a delightful balance between chewy and crunchy. Each bite reveals a savory tomato sauce paired with quality cheese that stretches delectably. It’s a classic New York slice, elevated just enough to leave a memorable impression.

But what truly caught me off guard were the outsized flavors of their lobster pierogis—these little pockets of joy are a must-try! Who knew a piece of New York could blend so beautifully with a Polish classic? The cocktail offerings are no slouch either, showcasing creativity while complementing the diverse menu—a refreshing twist that sets Little Donna's apart from the traditional pizzeria.

I must mention the staff, too! The knowledgeable and friendly service added an extra layer of joy to my visit, making me feel right at home. So if you’re hunting for the best New York style pizza in Baltimore, don’t miss out on this gem. You might just find your new favorite slice!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Baltimore County.

Filippo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Affordable pizza options
Variety in menu choices
Notable chicken quesadilla
Value for money deal
Good cheesesteak sub

Filippo's Pizzeria: A Slice of New York in Baltimore

Tucked away in the bustling streets of Baltimore, Filippo's Pizzeria really knows how to please pizza enthusiasts. I couldn't resist diving into their affordable pizza options, which perfectly mirror the spirit of a classic New York slice: crispy, yet foldable! The first bite was an invigorating mix of flavors, with the tomato sauce dancing gently under a blanket of bubbling cheese.

What really turned my head, however, was the delightful variety in menu choices. From classic pepperoni to inventive toppings, they seem to cater to all palates. I even found myself drawn to the notable chicken quesadilla, which surprised me pleasantly – a fun twist away from the traditional pizza fare.

For those keeping an eye on their wallet, Filippo's features a value for money deal that makes indulging guilt-free. And let's not overlook their good cheesesteak sub, which I paired with my pizza and found surprisingly delightful!

Overall, Filippo’s stands out as a charming option in the city, serving slices that remind you of New York while maintaining Baltimore's unique flair!

You might also want to check out the best new restaurants in Baltimore.

Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar

At Angeli’s Pizzeria & Bar, I discovered a slice of pizza perfection that takes me straight back to New York! The thin, foldable crust is a masterclass in balance—crispy yet chewy. Each bite bursts with robust tomato sauce and perfectly melted mozzarella. The toppings are generously applied, allowing flavors to mingle delightfully without overpowering. The ambiance is lively, making it a fantastic spot to indulge with friends or a late-night craving. Grab a slice (or two!) and let the tastes transport you. If you’re hunting for an authentic ny-style experience, Angeli’s is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best hamburgers in Baltimore.

TinyBrickOven

When I stepped into TinyBrickOven, the aroma of fresh dough and sizzling cheese instantly transported me to the bustling streets of New York. Their New York-style pizza boasts a perfectly crisp crust that holds its shape, even when topped with their rich, tangy tomato sauce and generous layers of melted mozzarella. Each bite is a delightful combination of flavors, with a hint of wood-fired smokiness that truly sets it apart. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a casual hangout. If you’re on the hunt for authentic slices in Baltimore, TinyBrickOven is a must-try! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Columbia.

Johnny Rad's Pizzeria Tavern

Stepping into Johnny Rad's Pizzeria Tavern feels like a slice of New York dropped into Baltimore. Their thin, crispy crust had just the right amount of char, providing the perfect foundation for a symphony of toppings. I savored the classic cheese slice, where the rich, tangy sauce danced beautifully with gooey mozzarella. Each bite was a delightful reminder of what true New York pizza should taste like. The cozy atmosphere and attentive staff made the experience even more enjoyable. If you're on a quest for the best pizza in Baltimore, Johnny Rad's is definitely worth a visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best crab in Baltimore.

Mario's Original Pizza & Pasta

Mario's Original Pizza & Pasta is a delightful gem in Baltimore's pizza scene! Upon stepping inside, the wonderful aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me, tempting my taste buds. I ordered a classic pepperoni slice, and it arrived with a crispy, yet chewy crust that embodied the essence of New York style. The gooey mozzarella was perfectly melted, and the punchy tomato sauce added a vibrant contrast. Each bite was filled with flavor, leaving me craving more! If you're seeking that authentic Big Apple experience, Mario's delivers with care and passion in every slice. Definitely a must-try for pizza lovers! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Annapolis.

Iggies Pizza

Iggies Pizza beckoned me with the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked crust, and it did not disappoint! The moment I sank my teeth into a slice, I was greeted by a perfect blend of crispy yet chewy dough, topped with rich marinara and gooey mozzarella that danced on my palate. Their classic Pepperoni was a triumph—each slice cradled just the right amount of toppings, creating a delightful balance. The atmosphere buzzed with charm, making it a perfect spot for pizza lovers. If you're chasing that genuine New York vibe in Baltimore, Iggies is truly a slice above the rest!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Canton Baltimore.

Di Pasquale's

Di Pasquale's is a delightful gem in Baltimore that captures the essence of classic New York style pizza. The crust is a perfect balance—crispy yet chewy, delivering that satisfying foldability crucial for a genuine slice. Each pie is generously topped, with fresh ingredients that elevate every bite. The margherita I sampled had a bright, vibrant flavor thanks to its aromatic basil and rich sauce. Atmosphere is warm and inviting, making it a great spot for pizza lovers. For anyone craving a taste of New York in Baltimore, Di Pasquale's is an absolute must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best breakfast in Columbia.

Matthew's Pizzeria

Matthew's Pizzeria is a delightful gem that transports you straight to the streets of New York with every bite. The crust is perfectly charred, offering that coveted crunch while remaining fluffy inside. Topped with a rich tomato sauce and generous mozzarella, each slice is a harmonious balance of flavors. I couldn’t resist their classic pepperoni, which added a nice spice without overpowering the cheese. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, making you feel right at home. If you're in search of genuine new york style pizza in Baltimore, you certainly can’t go wrong with Matthew's—it's a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Baltimore.

Ray’s NY Pizza & Pasta

From the moment I stepped into Ray’s NY Pizza & Pasta, the aroma of freshly baked dough wrapped around me like a warm hug. Their thin crust had that perfect crispness, allowing for a delightful fold, just like you'd find in the heart of Manhattan. The toppings were generously applied—fresh mozzarella and zesty tomato sauce danced harmoniously to create a slice that was both satisfying and unforgettable. Each bite made me feel like I was back in NYC. If you’re in search of an authentic experience, I wholeheartedly recommend indulging in Ray’s; it’s truly a slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best crabs in Annapolis.

Gil's Pizza

Gil's Pizza in Baltimore is a delightful surprise for any new york style pizza enthusiast. The moment I stepped in, the aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me, promising a satisfying meal. Their slices are perfectly thin and crispy, with just the right amount of tangy sauce and melty cheese that stretches with each bite. I was particularly taken by their pepperoni, which added a lovely crunch and burst of flavor. The casual vibe and friendly staff make it a perfect spot to enjoy a slice. With Gil's, Baltimore proves it can hold its own against the best of New York! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Severna Park.

Barfly's

Barfly's in Baltimore is a delightful find for pizza aficionados! As I took my first bite of their thin, crisp crust adorned with gooey mozzarella and tangy tomato sauce, I was transported straight to the streets of NYC. The generous toppings felt like a warm hug, while the perfectly charred edges added that signature touch. The atmosphere buzzes with a laid-back charm, making it a fantastic spot to unwind. Whether you’re grabbing a slice on the go or enjoying a whole pie with friends, Barfly's delivers a slice of New York magic right in the heart of Baltimore. 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Towson.